Tuesday, March 27, 2012
The Dreamer
Ryan, Pam Munoz and Sis, Peter. The Dreamer. New York: Scholastic Press, 2010.
The Dreamer is a fictionalized account of Chilean poet Pablo Neruda's childhood, written by Pam Munoz Ryan and illustrated by Peter Sis. It is an ALA Notable Children's Book for Older Readers. When Neruda was a child, he was known as Neftalí Reyes. He began to use Neruda as his pen name, taken from his favorite poet, and later legally changed his name to reflect this.
In the book, Neftalí is a daydreamer who finds beauty in many things. Rather than do his schoolwork, he imagines numbers on his page lazily floating around as he listens to raindrops. Neftalí's father is not supportive of his creativity and wants his son to have a "real job" in the future. Neftalí's father is a source of anguish and intimidation. Eventually, Neftalí gets a job at a newspaper with his uncle and publishes a political article that upsets his father. Neftalí's father ransacks his bedroom and burns all of his writing notebooks. Neftalí worries because he is set to publish a poem in local and university newspaper later that week. He decides to use the pen name Pablo Neruda. Neftalí says "he would use this name to save Father the humiliation of having a son who was a poet. Maybe he would use the name only until he became lost enough to find himself. Maybe he would even keep the name. It might take him places. After all, it had a rhythm like a locomotive chugging uphill."
It's hard to classify the genre of this book - it combines fiction, biography, poetry, and illustration into one sensory journey. I felt that the book was a bit difficult to follow at times, as the storylines jump around and are interrupted by poems and drawings, but these are also great interruptions that might prompt moments of introspection and analysis from readers. This book would work well at the middle school level, and would be great for students who are drawn to the arts. The end of the book also contains selected poems by Pablo Neruda. This book, then, would work well to tie together an author study unit about Neruda - students would read poetry, fiction, and could supplant with some biography.
Monday, March 26, 2012
Chinese Cinderella and The Secret Dragon Society
This novel is very well-written and could easily be used in a middle school classroom. I would probably use it for a 6th and 7th grade level though, simply because it is an easier read. There are lots of activities that could be done in conjunction with the novel, including researching China during the 1940s and learning about Cinderella stories from different cultures. Even though the novel has a female protagonist, I think it appeals to a diverse audience. Overall, I think this is a great multi-cultural novel to teach to the young middle school age.
Wolf Mark by Joseph Bruchac
The Long Season of Rain
The Collector by John Fowles
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, Sherman Alexie
Arnold must decide whether to abandon his traditional Native American culture and seek the best education for himself or continue to be a part of his Native American culture which is often only described as drug-infused, abusive, poor, and delinquent. The book has gained some controversy because of its explicit content dealing with sex, violence, and racial inequality; however, Alexie's novel also won the National Book Award for Young Adult Literature. Therefore, the teacher, along with the school administration must weigh the benefits and consequences of exposing adolescent readers to this extremely realistic depiction of Native American life.
The Westing Game
The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin is a novel about a group of people who are selected to live in an apartment complex. These families soon find out after the death of their mysterious neighbor that they have been named his heirs, but in order to collect their money they must play a game. They are paired off, given a set of clues, and are told to solve the mystery that the clues present. The novel follows each pair as they attempt to answer the questions posed to them as well as sort out some strange happenings that are going on at the apartment building.
I thought that this was an excellent novel to read with middle school students. There are many activities that you could assign that could relate to foreshadowing and predictions. It would also be an excellent novel to teach with the reciprocal teaching method. It is a good novel for any grade in middle school, and is interesting enough to be able to keep a reader's attention. My only criticism of the novel is that the multicultural aspects of it are few. The occupants of the apartment are comprised of people of different races, but the novel doesn't go into their cultures at all. Despite that though, I think it would be a really fun novel to read in class.
Copper Sun by Sharon Draper
The Skin I'm In
Flake, Sharon. The Skin I'm In. New York: Jump at the Sun/Hyperion for Children, 1998. Print.
Maleeka Madison struggles to fit in her high school and for good reason. Ever since her father died, her mother makes all of Maleeka's clothes in order to cope with the loss, making Maleeka the target for many of her classmates jokes. If that wasn't hard enough, she is also picked on for having very dark skin, which forces Maleeka to feel self conscious about the way she looks. This all changes however when Mrs. Saunders becomes her new English teacher at school. Mrs. Saunders is a strong, confident, and determined woman, most of which comes from dealing with a skin deformity that she was born with. Mrs. Saunders is the perfect role model for Maleeka to show that no matter how you look, you are undeniably beautiful. We follow Maleeka on her journey to fight peer pressure, bullying, and finally accept the way she is meant to be.
This book was a very quick read. The vocabulary was very simple and the book was under 200 pages. I think the book is more geared towards girls than boys and I think it would be very hard for boys to relate to Maleeka's character. All of the main characters are women, possibly making it difficult for boys to find interest in the book. I thought the book was interesting, however it didn't seem like a very creative story line and overall it was pretty predictable. I do not believe this book would be extremely effective in the classroom, but rather should be used for a student's personal read.
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
An Island Like You
An Island Like You: Stories of the Barrio by Judith Ortiz Cofer is a book about several Latina/os in New Jersey. Each story is different but they often intertwine with one another. What the struggle in this book is is with a multicultural identity. The characters in this book are struggling to find their place not only in their communities, but also within the US as a whole. I think this book is very very teachable. Everyone in the world knows what it's like to feel like you don't belong, be it in a group of people, at a certain school, or even in your own skin. This book could bring to light the fact that this feeling is cross-cultural. It also will teach kids that being an individual is something important and to stand up for what you believe in. The personal identity struggle is something that many students in 7th and 8th grade are struggling with anyway. If they can read about others who are in a similar stage, and have similar feelings they could really connect on a deeper level than simply reading to fulfill a book requirement.
Thirteen Reasons Why
Thirteen Reasons Why
By: Jay Asher
Summary:
This book is a creepy but exhilarating take on the snowball effect that caused the main character, Hannah Baker, to commit suicide. She creates a set of 7 cassette tapes for the people involved to listen to. All but 2 of these people belong on a “list” of wrong-doers who ruined her life at her new school. One of the “others” is the narrator we follow as he listens to these tapes over one long night. The book takes you through Hannah’s life, while the narrator reflects on his own, becoming more and more exhausted and upset as he reads them.
Teachability:
There are a few scenes in this novel that are not appropriate for young kids. They are sexually based and could be uncomfortable for younger or immature students. I would recommend this book for 8th grade at the earliest, and a more mature group at that. I like that there really are duel protagonists, male and female, with both perspectives alive in the text. I think that this would be hard to teach because of the extremely dark nature of the book, with no real redeeming qualities or breaks. Teaching this book about suicide for a high school girl could be too much for the classroom, but a mature literature group or individual book may be okay.
Monday, March 12, 2012
Hiroshima
This book follows the atomic bombing of Hiroshima in 1945. It's more of a novella then an actual novel, and incorporates nonfiction statistics with the fictional story of Sachi, a girl who survives the bombing. Yep provides facts about the planes that carried the bomb and the size of it, and gives a little background of why the bomb was dropped. He also gives statistics on the aftermath of the event: how many people died, how it affected the city, and what it meant for future wars between countries. Yep loosely follows the fictional Sachi's story. She and her sister, like all students, work to defend Japan against America, and the bomb drops while she is working. Her sister and father die and Sachi is left with extreme burns and loses movement in one arm. She ends up becoming part of a group called the Maidens that are flown to the U.S. and given surgeries for free. The themes of this book are the horrors of war, the atomic bomb in particular, and how it affects civilians.
This book was a very easy read- it would be good for 6th graders, probably too easy for 7th and 8th. There are no really graphic scenes and the language is not difficult at all. It is more nonfiction than fiction, Sachi's character is never really developed and the majority of the book is made up of information about the bombing, so I don't think it would appeal to students and I wouldn't choose to teach it. It would be a good book to suggest for independent reading during a World War II unit, or if you have to teach it you could use it as one of a few texts since it's relatively short.
Monster
Monster is about a sixteen year old African American boy named Steve Harmon as he is tried for felony murder, facing the death penalty or 25 years to life if he is convicted. He was allegedly the lookout at a convenience store before James King, also on trial with him, and Bobo, who testifies against them to reduce his own sentence, went in to rob the store owner, Mr. Nesbitt. In the tussle that ensued, Mr. Nesbitt was fatally shot. The book alternates between chapters written as a diary and a screenplay, which helps with the story's deep character development and emotionally-charged reading. The story contains flashbacks to Harmon's experience in film class in school and his life growing up in Harlem, as well as descriptions of life inside prison, his visits and relationships with his family members, and the proceedings of the court case. The story does end by stating whether Harmon has been found guilty or not, but the reader never finds out from Harmon's thoughts (in diary format) and screenplay whether he was involved in the crime.
While the vocabulary in the book is very simple, the format of this story would be appealing to students, and it would be engaging to have students act out different scenes throughout the book or write responses that mirror its style. The themes, including peer pressure, and race and the judicial system, would be interesting and complex topics to have discussions about as Monster is read. However, the sometimes graphic nature (with Harmon describing the sounds of sexual assault and beatings in the prison), and the overall themes make it more likely to be used in a classroom as an independent reading book. I would probably have it in my library in 7th and 8th grade, but I would be wary of having 6th graders read it.
In the Time of the Butterflies by Julia Alvarez
Monday, March 5, 2012
Flight
Flight by Sherman Alexie, published in New York by Black Cat, 2007.
Esperanza Rising by Pam Munos Ryan
Never judge a book by its cover—even if it has a little girl flying in the wind. I will confess that I was not excited to read this book because of both the title and cover. I’ve read an article before about how teachers have this assumption that girls will read books about boys, but not vice versa. I think to some extent, this is true; at least it is for me. However, I was pleasantly surprised as this book deals with an engaging plot and relevant issues.
Esperanza Rising is a coming of age story about Esperanza, a girl living in a politically turbulent Mexico. Her father is murdered early in the novel and the rest of the novel has to deal with gender issues about how the government has rendered women helpless and how Esperanza’s mother is being pressured to marry a corrupt politician. In the end, the book also references the race issue with migrant workers as the family moves to California to work on farms.
In teaching this novel, it might be hard to get boys in the classroom fully on board, but I think this text is an important one as it deals with important gender and race issues. So, although it might be difficult to teach, teachers will somehow just have to make it work :)
Ryan, Pam Munoz. Esperanza Rising. New York: Scholastic, 2000